Announcements

Welcome to the course! The classroom has been moved to CBA 4.338.

Class notes (in PDF form) are now linked by date, in the syllabus section after the readings.

 Contact Information

Daniel Bonevac
Department of Philosophy
University of Texas at Austin
1 University Station C3500
Austin, TX 78713
Waggener 403: 512-232-4333; FAX: 512-471-4806; bonevac@mail.utexas.edu
Office Hours: Wednesday 10-11:30

 Writing Philosophy
My UT site
Jim Pryor's Princeton site
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill site
Dartmouth College site

 Online Texts
Plato, Laches
Plato, Euthyphro
Plato, Apology
Plato, The Republic
Plato, Meno
Plato, Phaedrus
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics
Augustine, Confessions
Anselm, Freedom of the Will (Freedom of Choice)
Aquinas, Summa Theologica
Hume, Treatise of Human Nature
Kant, Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals
Bentham, Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation
Mill, On Liberty
Mill, Utilitarianism
Sidgwick, The Methods of Ethics
Pritchard, Does Moral Philosophy Rest on a Mistake?
Ross, The Right and the Good


 The Professor

Daniel Bonevac is Professor of Philosophy at The University of Texas at Austin. He has been teaching courses in philosophy for more than twenty-five years. His book Reduction in the Abstract Sciences (1982) received the Johnsonian Prize from The Journal of Philosophy. The author of five books and editor or co-editor of three others, Professor Bonevac's recent articles include "Against Conditional Obligation" (Noûs, 1998), "Sellars v. the Given" (Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 2002), "Reflection Without Equilibrium," Journal of Philosophy (July 2004), "Free Choice Permission Is Strong Permission" (Synthese, 2005, with Nicholas Asher), and "The Conditional Fallacy," (Philosophical Review, 2006, with Josh Dever and David Sosa).


PHL 325K

Ethical Theories

Raphael, The School of Athens



This course examines four central approaches to ethical theory on the contemporary scene-- virtue ethics, deontology, consequentialism, and intuitionism-- by a close reading of the texts from which they spring. Our discussion will not be limited to those texts; we will consider subsequent developments, especially recent contributions, and we will seek to identify and address the primary problems each tradition faces.

Syllabus

June 5, 6 Ethics and Ethical Theories
June 9-13 Common Sense Ethics: Intuitionism Pritchard, "Does Moral Philosophy Rest on a Mistake?"; Ross, The Right and the Good, I , The Right and the Good, II ; Confucius, Analects; Notes: June 9; June 10; June 11; June 12; June 13
June 16-20 Virtue Ethics Plato, Laches; Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics I-IV, VI, VII; Plato, Republic IV; Augustine, Confessions VIII, 9, 10; Anselm, On Freedom of the Will ; Aquinas, "The Difference Between Moral and Intellectual Virtues," Summa Theologica; Notes: June 16; June 17; June 18; June 19; June 20
June 23-27 Deontology Kant, Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals; "On a Supposed Right to Tell Lies from Benevolent Motives"; Notes: June 23; June 24; June 25; June 26; June 27
June 30-July 3 Consequentialism Bentham, Principles of Morals and Legislation, Chapters I-V; Pannomial Fragments; The Rationale of Reward, III, 1; A Table of the Springs of Action; Mill, "Of the Logic of Practice", A System of Logic; "Bentham"; Utilitarianism; Sidgwick, "The Meaning of Utilitarianism", Methods of Ethics; Notes: June 30; July 1; July 2; July 3
July 7-10 Class Presentations
July 12 All papers due

 Requirements

This is a substantial writing component course. Your course grade will rest primarily on your writing. The goal: an excellent 15 page (5000 word, more or less) paper on a topic of your choosing, relating to at least one of the approaches to ethical theory explored in this course. You will pursue this goal in five stages:

  1. Detailed notes on a session of the class, to be emailed to the professor within three days of that session. (10% of your grade.)
  2. A 1-3 page prospectus, explaining your topic, your objective, and how you plan to go about achieving it, due by June 28. (10% of your grade.)
  3. A draft of your paper, to be distributed to a group of students working on related topics as well as to the professor, due by July 5. (10% of your final grade.)
  4. A presentation of your draft to the class, and comments on other students' drafts, pointing out strengths and weaknesses, and giving advice for improvement, July 7-10. (10% of your final grade.)
  5. Your final paper, revised in light of comments from your group members and the professor, due by July 12. (60% of your final grade.)
Submit all of the above by emailing them to the professor.

A good paper will address an important topic; state clearly the thesis to be advanced; argue for that thesis clearly and compellingly; show an awareness of possible questions, objections, and counterarguments, indicating at least in outline how to respond to each; and show familiarity with some relevant secondary and contemporary literature. The Philosophers' Index is your friend.

Read carefully the advice on writing philosophy papers found on web sites linked from this page.



 Stanford Encyclopedia Articles

These articles are excellent overviews of areas central to the course. They also have terrific bibliographies.