Reading assignments
The readings for the course are
multidisciplinary, from the fields
of archaeology, art history, ancient history, philology, philosophy,
natural sciences, gender studies, sociology, economics, military
history, etc. There will be a LOT, and much of it contradictory!
Critical reading will be required. Expect to do a full week's worth of
reading, so don't put it off
until Tuesday night.....
We will not go over the readings in detail in class.
Instead, you
will be expected to ask intelligent questions about them and to
synthesize what you learned into class discussions.
|
5/6
Today's main readings are somewhat experimental: in the course of our
correspondence, John Collis kindly sent me two very recent, in fact yet
unpublished articles. One deals with the development and
popularity of the concept of the "Celts" during the 18th c. CE; the
other tackles current trends in Celtoskepticism head-on. I've
posted these to eReserves, along with a few associated texts:
A short but impassioned selection from Simon James's The Atlantic Celts; Anthony
Smith's very brief but excellent "Authenticity, antiquity and
archaeology"
Ray Karl's short review chapter on "Celtoscepticism"
Read in Cunliffe: Ch. 14
Read in Collis: Ch. 9-11 (very short)
Those who have acquired Morse will find yourselves in your element now
and having a high old time, as Morse spares no painful detail!!
Be prepared to slug it out over Collis's title: "To be, or not to be, a
Celt. Does it really matter?"
Hint: to keep everyone's
arguments straight, it would be a VERY good idea to write a brief
precis, outline or summary of each article or chapter! This can get VERY confusing ...
4/29
Today's guest lecturers will take us into the Roman period, and into
the early Christian era, not in that order -- expect culture
shock! Please be sure to do the readings!!
Primary texts: St Patrick's "Confession" -- available on eReserves,
on-line in
translation (and for those who'd like to have a go at the Latin
;-).)
The short ethnographic section of Caesar
starting at Book 6.11 -- available on eReserves, on our Ancient
Sources page or at Wikisource
Read in Cunliffe: Ch. 12-13; Read in Kruta: "The Romanization of
Gaul," "The Island Celts."
Read the short articles on eRes: Woolf on "Beyond Romans and Natives"
and Webster on "'Interpretatio': Roman Word Power and the Celtic Gods"
4/22
Small Map Quiz today - locate on map and say why we study the following:
Cannae
|
Zone: Bohemia |
River: Duero
|
Danebury
|
Zone: Celtiberians
(the Meseta) |
River: Ebro
|
Entremont
|
Zone: Great
Hungarian Plain |
River: Elbe
|
Londinium
|
Zone: Pyrennees
|
River Garonne
|
Numantia
|
|
River: Rubicon
|
Pergamon
|
|
River: Thames |
Ribemont-sur-Ancre
|
|
|
Snettisham
|
|
|
Stradonice
|
|
|
Telamon
|
|
|
Toulouse
|
|
|
Zavist
|
|
|
We will be looking at some of the ancient "Celtic" languages and
language groups -- primarily the Continental ones. We will not
get hung up on modern linguistic controversies ... too much ...
If you have purchased Morse, How the
Celts Came to Britain: Ancient Skulls and the Birth of Archaeology,
this is a good time to curl up and give him a good read -- he is
absolutely fascinating and it's a rip-roaring story!
Read in Koch & Carey, Chapter 1 (just 4 pages, very
speculative! - on reserves)
This week's red-light duelling critical readings (on eReserves): "The Longue
Durée
of Genetic Ancestry: Multiple Genetic Marker Systems and Celtic Origins
on the Atlantic Facade of Europe" of 2004, one of hundreds of similar
articles appearing within the past decade -- you do
not need to get a degree in genetics, just get the gist of the argument
and the nature of the evidence. Compare Sims-Williams, "Genetics,
linguistics, and prehistory: thinking big and thinking straight."
Read in Cunliffe: Ch. 11.
Read in Kruta: "The Language and Writing of the Early Celts," "The
Oppida of the Second and First Centuries BC,"
"Celtic Society in the First Century BC"
Read in The Celtic World: "The Early Celts" and "The First
Towns," on eRes.
4/15
Keep those rewrites and works in progress coming! Use
c.m.witt@gmail.com if I don't respond to your mail.
Today we will take a wild journey around the peripheral "Celtic" areas.
We will have a guest speaker -
Dr. Mariah Wade - who excavates in western
Iberia!
Go to eKeltoi:
Volume 6 and read in whatever form you prefer: "The Celts in
Iberia: An Overview" by Alberto J. Lorrio and Gonzalo Ruiz
Zapatero
On eReserves: Sanchez-Moreno on Iberian Hospitality; Rose on Text &
Image in Celtiberia.
Read in Kruta: "The Celts in Italy," "The Transpadane Celts," "The
Carpathian Basin," "The Celts of the
Iberian Peninsula," "Armorica" -- most of these are short &
sweet. You do NOT have to memorize any unpronounceable or
unspellable names, unless they are mentioned multiple times.
Read in Cunliffe: Ch. 7, 8, 9
Read in Collis: Ch. 6, "Locating the Celts" and Ch. 8,
"Archaeology of the Celts"
Movies: written assignment for each film (group or
individual):
1) Your readings for today have led you to expect certain
manifestations of belief regarding the family and ancestors. How
does/does not the film deal with this issue?
2) Your readings for today have led you to expect certain
manifestations of belief regarding the military and the war dead.
How does/does not the film deal with this issue?
3) Discuss how the film elects to portray the relations between
the "Celts" and the Romans. Which does the filmmaker consider the
"higher" culture? What specific stylistic and thematic choices were
made to convey this preference?
4) Discuss the choices the filmmaker made in portraying the female
characters. Did these choices accord with what you have read so far in
this course, or did they depart from your readings, or both? What
is the effect of those choices?
4/8
Keep those rewrites coming! And please be working on Paper 3!
Brainstorm together, use the writing center, whatever it takes ...Email
me at
c.m.witt@gmail.com if I don't respond to your @mail.
Since we keep mentioning "ritual" and "sacred," let's find
out what we're really talking about ...
Read in Kruta: "Celtic Religion"
and "Celtic Religion and Mythology" (on PCL Reserves)
Read in Cunliffe: Ch. 10.
Read in The Celtic World: "The Gods and the
Supernatural," "Ritual and the Druids," "Burial and the
Otherworld" and "Sanctuaries
and Sacred Places" (on PCL Reserves).
Read in Freeman, chapter on Religion (on eReserves).
Read in Rankin Ch. 14 with a large grain of salt, and be ready to
formulate your thoughts about "Druids"
Study the oppidum, esp. the sanctuaries and sculptures, at Entremont: http://www.culture.gouv.fr/culture/arcnat/entremont/en/index2.html
(in English!!)
On those fascinating "Belgic" bone sanctuaries -- [example of
a topic requiring mastery of French!]
Read from Archaeology 2001
vol 54/2: Jean-Louis Brunaux on Gallic
Blood (oooh ...) re: the sanctuaries at Gournay-sur-Aronde and
Ribemont-sur-Ancre. There are additional articles with illustrations on
eRes; the articles are in French, but the illustrations are very
helpful anyway. The web sites are: Gournay-sur-Aronde
and Ribemont-sur-Ancre
(see 2002
and 2003
(pdf) excavation reports).
4/1
Read in The Celtic World: "Seafaring," "Coinage," and
"Trade and Exchange" (on eReserves)
Read selections from Celtic Chiefdom, Celtic State, B. Arnold
and D.B. Gibson, eds, 1995 (on eReserves)
Read in Kruta: "Coinage," "Celtic Writing" (on PCL Reserves)
Read
in Megaws: Chapter 5.
Please hand in rewrites of Paper 1 and start thinking about topics for
your Final Research Paper, see assignment.
3/24
Creative Papers due. Also, I'm expecting rewrites of Paper 1 --
let's not get backlogged.
Catch up on ALL readings! Be prepared to discuss intelligently,
and synthsize material.
We will concentrate on issues raised by Wells in Beyond Celts,
Germans and Scythians.
BTW, Peter Wells will be in San Antonio speaking on the
Arminius Battle
on April 1; see the Google calendar (feel free to subscribe &
attend any event:
3/10
No, not all of this week's work will be hands-on ... it is not yet
Spring Break, so let's be scholarly about "Celtic" drinking!
Read
Shefton: "Massalia and Colonization" on eReserves. Brian Shefton's
thinking on the "colonization"/Hellenization of Europe has evolved
since this article; it remains one of the best summations of the known
material.
Read Bettina Arnold's excellent short article on "'Honorary Males' or
Women of
Substance? Gender, Status and Power in Iron-Age Europe" (on eReserves
in Cultural).
Read Bettina Arnold's short article on "Power
Drinking in Iron Age Europe" and John Collis's response
in British Archaeology, 2001. (This is a reputable journal).
Read my short essay
on drinking -- sorry to subject you to it, but most of the
sources are in German.
As a special treat, read "MacDatho's
Pig" at Vassar
(early Irish, Ulster Cycle -- it takes place in Leinster but
features the rival groups of Ulster/Ulaid and Connaught) -- includes
the original emended text, if you want to give it a whirl (also in Koch
& Carey). You will
encounter old friends like Leary (Leogaire), Conall Cernach,
Conchobar, and others at "Bricriu's Feast" (in Koch and Carey;
also on eRes
in very old translation). Think about the social and political aspects
and
roles of the feast, as well as any insight these literary works
might give into the meaning of feasting during the Iron Age.
(Completely voluntary: also in Cultural, a recent article by Doris Edel
on "'Bodily matters' in early Irish narrative literature," for those of
a scatological bent, or those a bit worried about all the sex &,
er, stuff in this lit). Have fun!
3/4
Please get a good running start on Paper 2.
This is your "Creative" paper; your chance to take on a persona
entirely different from your own -- or exactly similar to yourself
... As restrictive as the instructions for Paper 1 are, those for
Paper 2 give your imagination free rein -- except that you can't make
up the facts about Iron Age Europe. So go to town, but keep it
real, and of course watch your writing.
Readings: Megaws Ch. 4, review Kruta "The Celts and
their Movements in the Third Century B.C.," "Weaponry," and
"Mercenary
Activity." (on PCL Reserves). Review Wells.
This is your week to catch up on what you have not been able to finish
in the previous weeks, or review what you only skimmed, paying
particular attention to the ways in which the ancient sources are used
by your secondary authors to explicate (or not) the archaeological
evidence. Be prepared to discuss the following issues intelligently in
class: The Celtic Sack of Rome; the attack on Delphi;
"Celtic" military developments and activities in the 4th - 3rd
centuries BCE; movements of "Cetic" peoples during this period and
their possible motivations; Greek and Latin ethnographies and
historiographies of the Celts/Gauls; the effects of the actions of the
northern barbarians on the Mediterranean peoples.
2/25
Quiz 1
Ah, those Classical sources. We are now in the era of
ever-increasing interaction between Iron Age Europeans and
Mediterranean peoples who write stuff down ...
Please read the short excerpts from Polybius, Diodorus, Caesar, Strabo,
Livy, and Cassius Dio on your Literary
Sources page as
well as excerpts of Athenaeus
(Poseidonios) . Note: Much of this is conveniently translated in
Freeman (eReserves) and Koch & Carey (optional book).
Read Pausanias' accounts of the Gauls at Delphi (excerpts from Books 1
and 10); read "The Soteria at Delphi" and "Myth & History II: the
Sack of Rome" on eRes.
Read "Reconstructing Poseidonios' Celtic Ethnography," (on eReserves)
-- these last three are examples of very different approaches to the
material, while at the same time exhibiting some of the very best in
historiography. These are writers to learn from and emulate (esp.
Williams)!
Read in Megaws Chapters 2 and 3.
Read "The Celts in France" from Green, The Celtic World (also
on eRes and 2-day Reserves in PCL).
Read P. Wells, Beyond Celts,
Germans and Scythians (it's
short) and really think about how we use the sources we have been given
and issues of identity in the kinds of
societies we are looking at. (also on PCL Reserves)
2/18
Description due
Happy Val's!
bonus points: what's the ancient origin of
Valentine's Day?
In discussing funerary finds, we have concentrated mainly on
human remains and a limited class of objects; today we will look at a
broader spectrum of craft production. In addition, we will discuss
various aspects of interpretation of works of "Celtic" art.
The fourth century is
known as the time of the
"migrations,"
and thus a period of militarization. We will delve into the
classical sources, most of which are devoted to warfare. Note as you
are reading that we have only the words of the enemies of the Celts.
We will also engage with the archaeological finds pertaining to arms,
armor and warfare.
Chapters 4 and 5 in Cunliffe.
Read in Rankin chs 4, 6 and 5 (it makes more sense
in that order, I find.)
In Kruta, "The Celts and their Gold," "Agriculture,""Handicrafts,"
"Mercenary
Activity."
Read in The Celtic World: "Appearance, Life and
Leisure,""Power, Politics and Status," "Rural
Life and Farming," and "Resources and Industry."
Read critically Otto-Herman Frey, "A New Approach" (on eReserves)
2/11
In Rankin read Ch 13 (this is also available on-line via UT Library).
Read the handy summary "The Celts in Classical
Eyes," from Green, The Celtic World (also on eRes).
Read Arnold's short article on "'Honorary Males' or Women of
Substance? Gender, Status and Power in Iron-Age Europe" (on eRes).
Read Knüsel's short article from a very different point of view:
" "More Circe than Cassandra" (on eRes).
In Kruta, "The Princely Tombs of
Burgundy," "The Celtic Princes of Hohenasperg," "The Princely Tombs of
the Celts in the Middle
Rhineland," "The Vix Settlement and the Tomb of the Princess,"
"Kleinaspergle near Asperg," "The Waldalgesheim Tomb," "The First
Historical
Expansion: Fourth Century
BCE."
Some more recent archaeology: the very brief report "New archaeological
discoveries through magnetic gradiometry: The early Celtic settlement
on Mont Lassois, France" (on eRes).
In Kruta, "Weaponry."
In Cunliffe, Ch. 5.
Read "The Army, Weapons and Fighting" and
"Fortifications
and defenses," both from Green, on eRes.
2/4
This week we are talking in depth (sorry) about
burials. We always talk about burials, you say. This is true,
but let us be sure that we define our terms and think about the
interpretation of ancient burial in a differentiated manner. To that
end, let us read the brilliant Mike Parker Pearson on The Archaeology
of Death and Burial (on eReserves in the Archaeology folder) --
2
very short chapters. MPP writes exceedingly clearly and well, an
excellent model. As a special treat, if you like, you might want
to read a commented translation of Ibn
Fadlan's description of the Rus ship burial rite (short excerpt).
In Freeman, read the short selections on Women (copy on
eReserves).
In Cunliffe, read 27 "Archaeology"-67.
In Kruta, 80-102 (also on eRes as "Celtic Princes") Note that this
volume is not translated well and is full of typos. Very old-school.
But it has nice pictures ... Practice seeing! Please be thinking about
an object that you would like to describe for your first written
assignment.
In Megaws, read through p. 49 -- thoroughly ....
Hint: If you have a terrible
visual memory, you might want to
start making database records or index cards for specific objects
seen in class. Include all information gleaned from your reading. If
you start now, you won't be overwhelmed.
1/21-28
On eReserves
for this class: "Gods and Heroes of the European Bronze Age" (short
selections); "Our Ancestors the Gauls," "The Contested Past."
in
Kruta (the blue Celts book),
pp. 39-49: Poppi on "The Archaeological Sources" (on eRes in the
Archaeology folder).
In Megaw and Megaw Celtic Art
: Introduction.
If your grasp of modern European
geography is not what it should
be, make use of the maps provided on eReserves in the "Introductory"
folder -- or any recent atlas -- and make sure you know where the
major rivers, seas, mountain ranges, and modern countries are located.
Last
updated,Wednesday, 04-Feb-2009 20:07:06 CST
|