What is Macro Practice in Social Work?
According to Netting et. al. (1993) it is:
-
Professionally directed intervention
-
Designed to bring about planned change
-
Macro systems (organizations and communities)
Conceptualizing Systems in Macro Practice
Client system: an individual, family, group, organization,
or community who will ultimately benefit from our intervention.
Target system: the individual, group, organization,
or community to be changed or influenced to achieve our goals.
Change agent system: the individual who initiates
the macro change system.
Action system: Those people who agree and are committed
to working in order to attain the proposed macro change.
Levels of Social Work Intervention
Micro Level: Intervention with individuals.
Mezzo Level: Intervention with family and groups.
Macro Level: Intervention with programs, organizations,
and/or communities.
Social Justice and Social Work Practice
Definitions of social justice
Social justice has to do with fairness and equity in the
distribution of opportunity, in the treatment of individuals, in the assurance
of personal and economic security, and the protection of civil and human
rights. (Paul Ylvisaker)
An ideal condition in which all members of a society have
the same basic rights, protection, opportunities, obligations, and social
benefits. (The Social Work Dictionary)
Personal responsibility, self-help, and social
justice
(Etzioni, 1993, p. 143-147)
Communitarian position on social justice has the following
elements:
-
People have a moral responsibility to help themselves as
best they can.
-
When individuals are unable to help themselves, it is the
responsibility of those closest to them to help.
-
As a rule, every community ought to be expected to do the
best it can to take care of its own.
-
Societies (collections of communities) must help communities
whose ability to help their members is severely limited.
-
Social justice is an inter-community issue, not only an intra-community
matter.
Communitarian thesis
(Etzioni, 1993, pages 1-2)
-
Law and order can be restored without turning the country
of the free into a police state.
-
The family can be saved without forcing women to stay at
home or otherwise violating their rights.
-
Schools can provide essential moral education without indoctrinating
young people.
-
People can live in communities without turning into vigilantes
and becoming hostile to one another.
-
Strong rights presume strong responsibilities
-
The pursuit of self-interest can be balanced with a commitment
to the community.
-
Public interest can reign without denying the legitimate
interests of the various constituencies that make up America.
Excerpt from The Careless Society (McKnight), pages 98-99:
My father recently told me that during the New Deal when
Franklin Roosevelt was president, most people understood this country as
a place where there were interests that were the enemies of the
common people. But, he said, today we identify the enemy of the people
as poverty, sickness, and disease. My father insists that the enemy isn't
poverty, sickness, and disease. He argues that the enemy is a set of institutions
and interests that are advantaged by clienthood and dependency. . . . .
. The enemy is a set of interests that need dependency masked as service.
What is your reaction to this statement?
Do you think he would identify social work as one of those
interests?
Disabling Effects of Professionalized Assumptions
of Need
(McKnight, 1995, pages 43-45)
1. Translation of need into deficiency.
2. Placing the perceived deficiency in the
client.
3. Specialization à
advanced technique and technology.
Professionalized Service Systems and Needs
(McKnight, 1995, page 46)
Definition of Client Need
-
You are deficient
-
You are the problem
-
You have a collection of problems
The Needs of Professionalized Service Systems
-
We need deficiency
-
The economic unit we need it individuals
-
The productive economic unit we need is an individual
with multiple needs
Two Basic Premises of Human Services
(McKnight, 1995, page 113)
-
Human service interventions have negative effects as well
as benefits.
-
Human service interventions are only one way to address the
conditions of people who are labeled.
The Iron Rule (Saul Alinsky)
Never do for people what they can do for themselves.
Return to transparencies
Return to syllabus