Exercise A, Grade 8:
Reading the Text
to Establish the Discourse Pattern in the Scene
Students are told to look at the
conversation in Scene 5 in terms of questions and
answers. They are to note the times Beckmann asks
questions and gets an answer, as opposed to the times when
Beckmann asks questions and is asked a question in
return.
After establishing by example
that the question / question pattern occurs frequently, the
teacher can ask students what it usually means when people
answer questions with a question. Students can reflect in
English or German about how counter-questions enable someone
to avoid giving answers. They will probably recognize
counter-questions as ploys to dominate a conversation by
directing it on the interviewees' terms rather than by
responding to interviewers' attempts to obtain information
from them.
The teacher would model such a
discourses and ask the class to practice this discursive
technique either in German in order to experience its
affective impact and prepare to act out the Beckmann /
Kramer exchange. Typical mini-discourses between
students (often using particles to mark changes in emphasis
within sentences):
After that, they can be asked to
read part of the Beckmann exchanges out loud, with the
correct intonation (with one sentence countering the
other).