The following article is from Medieval France: An Encyclopedia
, eds. W. Kibler and G. Zinn. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc, 1995.
HUNDRED YEARS' WAR
. Posterity has bestowed the name "Hundred Years' War" on the series of Anglo-French
conflicts that occurred between 1337 and 1453. Two major issues were at stake: (1)
the claim of English kings to be rightful kings of France and (2) the irritations
arising from the fact that the king of England, as duke of Aquitaine, was a liege vassal
of the king of France. The dynastic claim to the French throne was important to
Edward III but was tenuous at best in the 15th century. The feudal status of Aquitaine,
regarded by some scholars as the key to the whole conflict, was eliminated by the expulsion
of the English from southwestern France in 1453.
There were, in fact, three wars of particular intensity, each of 20 years' duration,
preceded and followed by lesser conflicts. The "Edwardian" war of 1340-60 was dominated
by Edward III of England. The "Caroline" war of 1369-89 was dominated by the military establishment of Charles V of France. The "Lancastrian" war of 1415-35 was dominated
by Henry V of England and his brother John, duke of Bedford. Besides these three
major conflicts, there was indecisive Anglo-French fighting in the period 1294-1303, 1323-25, 1337-39, and 1436-44, plus the French campaign of reconquest (1449-53),
an abortive English invasion in 1475, and various war scares at other times.
The periods of intermittent conflict after 1294 were marked by fairly easy French
victories that gave way to stalemate, but each monarchy also suffered one humiliating
defeat at the hands of a supposedly inferior neighbor, Flanders (1302) and Scotland
(1314) respectively. These were the first of many other European states to be drawn
into the Anglo-French struggle over the course of a century.
In 1340, when Edward III first called himself king of France, the opposing kings assembled
large and expensive armies which confronted each other without engaging in decisive
action, to the annoyance of taxpayers on both sides of the Channel. A war of succession in Brittany broke out in 1341 and breathed new life into the Anglo-French
war. France was weakened by a tradition of not collecting taxes in time of truce,
and especially by internal
divisions in which important segments of the politically influential classes opposed
the government. Edward launched two well-organized campaigns, about a decade apart.
The first of these, in 1345-47, produced decisive English victories at Auberoche
in the southwest (1345), Crécy (1346) and Calais (1347) in the north, and La Roche-Derrien
(1347) in Brittany. The crisis caused by the Black Death then intervened, but the
second great campaign began in 1355, when the Prince of Wales ravaged upper Languedoc. In the next year, he defeated and captured John II at Poitiers. France was virtually
paralysed by social strife, political rivalries, and an empty treasury, while her
captive king attempted to negotiate a treaty.
Six centuries of historical commentary have failed to give a satisfactory explanation
for the French defeats. The noble knights, specialists in the traditional tactics
of heavy cavalry, seemed reluctant to appreciate the military value of non-noble
infantry, to adapt to the problems posed by new and more powerful missile weapons, and
to place coordination and discipline ahead of personal glory or the opportunity for
booty. Yet neither nobles nor heavy cavalry were obsolescent in 1350 as some have
claimed, and we still await a convincing explanation of the reasons for their shortcomings
in the 14th century.
Financial exigencies may have influenced the war in ways that have not received adequate
emphasis. For Edward III, it was cheaper to transport quantities of longbowmen across
the Channel than to send an army made up exclusively of heavy cavalry. For the French government in 1357-60, it was financially impossible to assemble a large force
and therefore desirable to avoid battle. The pitched battle had been the key to
English success. When Edward III, in his final invasion of France (1359-60), failed
to bring the French to battle, he had to conclude the treaty of Brétigny, which gave
him possession of all of Aquitaine but was less favorable to him than earlier peace
proposals.
The Edwardian war was, nevertheless, an English victory and a French defeat. When
it ended, France was plunged into even greater misery by the ravages of unemployed
troops (routiers
). This scourge forced people to acquiesce in a much higher level of taxation for
military purposes than would have been conceivable a few years earlier. Just as
important was the crown's rapprochement
with the disaffected nobility of the north and west. This regional aristocracy became
the core of a regularly financed French army at a time when England began to face
weak and divided leadership.
The war resumed in 1369 when Charles V agreed to accept appeals from Gascon lords
who chafed under English rule. The Caroline war of the next twenty years was bitter
and destructive but lacked dramatic battles. Bertrand du Guesclin (constable of
France, 1370-80) was a master at the tactics of the routiers
. His close associate and successor as constable, Olivier de Clisson, exerted a strong
influence against pitched battles and commanded the respect of the northwestern nobles.
Under these two able Bretons, the French regained large amounts of territory while the English squandered resources on expeditions that inflicted great damage without
producing strategic results. Yet England did retain key ports in France like Bordeaux,
Brest, Cherbourg, and Calais, while French attempts to carry the war across the Channel in the 1380s did not succeed.
Peace negotiations (1389-96) produced a prolonged lull in the war but no definitive
settlement, and the advantage in leadership swung back to England. The French military
elite suffered dreadful losses on crusade at Nicopolis (1396) and became badly divided during the mental incapacity of Charles VI, as the dukes of Burgundy engaged in
a power struggle with the Orléans/Armagnac faction. The English reopened the conflict,
inaugurating the Lancastrian war in 1415 and winning a crushing victory at Agincourt in October of that year. The weakened nobility of northwestern France was decimated
by death or capture. Leaderless Norman lordships were in no position to halt Henry
V's subsequent conquest of the region. Supported by Burgundy after the murder of
John the Fearless in 1419, Henry secured the treaty of Troyes in 1420 which acknowledged
him as heir to the French throne. His early death did not immediately change the
situation because his able brother, John of Bedford, continued to advance, defeating
the French badly at Verneuil (1424) and overrunning Anjou and Maine.
A new stalemate ensued only after the English failed to take Orléans in 1428-29.
In stopping their advance, the French found an unlikely group of leaders: the bastard
of Orléans, Jean de Dunois; the routier
captain, La Hire; the young, rich, and unstable marshal, Gilles de Rais; and, most
celebrated of all, the teen-aged visionary, Jeanne d'Arc. The presence of Jeanne
seems to have had an inspirational effect on French morale and a correspondingly
negative impact on the English. Jeanne was involved in several French victories that culminated
in the coronation of Charles VII at Reims, but in 1430 she fell into Burgundian hands
and the English, who accused her of heresy and sorcery, had her executed in 1431.
The pendulum of leadership began swinging back in favor of the French after the ouster
of Georges de La Trémoille from court in 1433 and the rise of Arthur de Richemont,
who had been constable since 1425 and favored a rapprochement
with Burgundy. The English did not join in the Franco-Burgundian treaty of 1435
and the death of Bedford was a blow to Lancastrian unity. Richemont regained Paris
in 1436 but after a new stalement the two sides concluded a five-year truce in 1444.
While the French were rebuilding Charles V's system of regular taxes and a salaried army,
England began to suffer from problems resembling those which had afflicted France
at the turn of the century--princely rivalries around a weak and mentally unstable
king. The French mastery of firearms rivalled the earlier English success with the longbow.
When the truce expired, French victories at Formigny (1450) and Castillon (1453)
sealed their rapid reconquests of Normandy and Aquitaine respectively.
No treaty ended the Hundred Years' War, but a new Anglo-Burgundian alliance in the
1470s was thwarted by the erratic but skillful Louis XI. England's recurrent internal
problems and the permanence of France's restored fiscal and military institutions
gave the Valois monarchy strength and stability at last. These factors, and a measure
of good luck, permitted the crown to regain control of several important territories--Burgundy
(1477), Anjou, Maine, and Provence (1481), Brittany (1493), and Orléans (1498)--and to become a major European power. [John B. Henneman]
Contamine, Philippe. Guerre, état et société à la fin du moyen âge
. Paris: Mouton, 1971.
Favier, Jean. La Guerre de cent ans
. Paris: Fayard, 1980.
Perroy, Edouard. The Hundred Years War
, trans. W. B. Wells. London: Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1951.