Note: footnotes and appendices are not included with this electronic version.
Knowledge, Skills and Abilities Required for Entry-Level Jobs in the Technology Industries and the Related Supply and Service Industries.
Introduction
The EnterTech Project seeks to create a business-validated, competency-based instructional program that prepares learners with the knowledge, skills and abilities necessary to be a graduate trainable for entry-level jobs in technology industries and related supply and service industries or a graduate prepared to continue their education.
The EnterTech Project was conceived to address several convergent issues:
As a collaborative effort between industry partners, educators, government and community stakeholders, the EnterTech project can affect change by creating a training program concentrated on technology industry needs. Technology industry jobs provide opportunities for improved employment outcomes, including sustainable wages, career pathways and continued skill improvement, for EnterTech targeted learners.
EnterTech Project coalition members (Appendix A) in technology companies were utilized to gather the following information:
Additional information on industry growth and needs projections were obtained from the Texas State Occupational Information Coordinating Committee (SOICC).
Two EnterTech Project advisory teams provided reviews and recommendations in the process of determining the knowledge, skills and abilities matrix: The Resources, Knowledge, Skills and Abilities Team and the Curriculum Design Team (membership listings and team descriptions in Appendix B). The teams provided feedback on job descriptions, industry data, related curriculum and workforce training programs, and jobs to be profiled.
Accordingly, the data for this report was collected through researching and analyzing:
Whereas job profiling activities are ongoing, this report details the research and information resources utilized to-date and the resultant matrix of the knowledge, skills and abilities required of the EnterTech Project graduate and by technology industry employers.
Section 1. Research and analyze available information relating to industry growth, employer staffing needs, and best paying entry-level jobs.
Through the year 2005 almost half of all new manufacturing jobs in Texas are expected to be in industries related to high technology, including computers, semiconductors, and telecommunications equipment. Texas high technology industries added 69,000 new jobs between 1990 and 1996, more than any other state, according to the American Electronics Association. The Texas State Comptroller Office projects an additional creation of 51,000 technology jobs in Texas during the next four years.
Employment Comparisons
Select Industries in 1996
More occupationally targeted projections are available from the SOICC Occupational and Skill Computer-Assisted Researcher (OSCAR). A review of entry- level technology industry jobs within the OSCAR database revealed the following annual growth rates:
Occupation |
Projected Annual Job Openings through 2005 | Employment Increase |
| Electric and Electronic Equipment Assemblers Precision | 455 | 20.72% |
| Electric and Electronic Inspectors and Testers | 360 | 19.57% |
| Electronic Components Assemblers | 710 | 29.47% |
| Electronic Semiconductor Processors | 240 | 11.97% |
| Electronic Semiconductor Test and Development Technicians | 240 | 11.97% |
| Materials Inspectors | 360 | 19.57% |
| Precision Devices Inspectors and Testers | 360 | 19.57% |
| Production, Planning and Expediting Clerks | 685 | 28.62% |
| Shipping, Receiving and Traffic Clerks | 1955 | 24.73% |
Whereas service sector jobs represent the fastest growing employment sector within Texas and indeed nationally, high-tech industries provide a greater increase in real wages for individuals than do wages available in the service industry. For example, The Monthly Labor Review indicates that within the United States, average weekly earnings for blue-collar workers in electronic manufacturing in 1997 were $533.40 per week; conversely, the average weekly earnings for workers in service industries was $400.33 per week.
Most service sector jobs begin at minimum wage, $5.15 per hour. A survey of EnterTech employer coalition members reported an average starting wage of $9 per hour for positions such as Assembler, Machine Operator, Manufacturing Associate, Material Handler, Production Associate, and Warehouse/Shipping Clerk.
Appendix C provides the EnterTech employer survey results, including wages and job demands for entry-level positions in these technology companies.
A focus on high-tech workforce training can raise the standard of living for Texas residents with skills needed by technology industries. Texas will not only benefit from an increase in real wage income for it residents, but will also begin to build the support needed to attract new high-tech industries, and continue its success in its exports of computers and electronics.
The Texas Technology Survey of 1997, conducted by the Governors Science and Technology Council, found a growing workforce shortage among high-tech industry, with more than 60% of the companies reporting unfilled jobs. The survey also revealed significant skill gaps in Texas workers. More than 90% of the surveyed companies said their workforce lacked some essential skills, such as computer skills, industry-specific skills, problem-solving skills or communication skills.
A national survey conducted by the Economic and Social Research Institute found employers value reliable workers with a positive attitude more than any other quality. "Education, technical training, and even prior work experience do not appear as important as good attitude, responsible work habits, and good references."
Employers repeatedly noted they are willing and able to teach job-related tasks, but it is much harder to teach a person to be a "good worker."
Job Candidate Qualities Rated as Most Important by Employers
(top three choices combined)
Current Employment By Training Category
Texas 1992
In other words, as one employer said, "Business doesnt need a trained graduate. What business needs is a graduate who is trainable."
At the October 9, 1998 EnterTech Coalition Member meeting, participants were asked to list the traits, attitudes, or characteristics most desirable in the entry-level worker. Most often cited responses were:
The national, state and local employer surveys indicate strong preferences for employees with self-management knowledge, employability skills, and on-the-job learning abilities. Therefore, the EnterTech curriculum should likewise emphasis the collaborative and interpersonal skills required by employers while providing refresher exercises in the basic academic skills.
Section 2. Research and analyze available information relating to knowledge, skills and abilities required for entry-level jobs in the technology industries and the related supply and service industries.
To begin evaluating the knowledge, skills and abilities required for the EnterTech curriculum, various forms of information were reviewed as follows:
2.1 current workforce training;
2.2 national skills standards, and
2.3 job descriptions and tasks lists of entry-level positions in technology industries.
2.1 Current Workforce Training
Appendix D contains the summary of 118 educational products reviewed by the EnterTech production team. The publishers and titles were recommended by EnterTech coalition members and by ACT Inc., the creator of Work Keys, a workplace skills standard and assessment system.
The Work Keys system is a metric that describes skill requirements for specific jobs and the competencies required by the incumbent workers as "skill levels." Each skill level describes the skill area in terms of specific proficiencies. The levels are used for instructional development that can accurately prepare learners for the demands of the workplace.
The Work Keys skills levels provide a systematic and defined hierarchy by which curriculum could be evaluated and compared. The curriculum review was intended to identify best practices, and to avoid unnecessary duplication of effective and affordable products available within the marketplace.
From this initial review, the team distilled the curricula most aligned to the EnterTech Project goals into a matrix with the Work Keys skill components. The following publishers and their curricula were integrated into the matrix:
The completed matrix is in Appendix E.
Additionally, the following Texas-specific training programs and skills standards were reviewed for instructional practices and skills sets:
2.2 National Skills Standards
Competencies also were evaluated and extracted from national skill standards such as the Comprehensive Adult Student Assessment System (CASAS), the ACT Work Keys system, and the U.S. Department of Labor Secretary's Commission on Achieving Necessary Skills (SCANS),.
CASAS competencies are organized into the following categories:
Work Keys targets for instruction are organized into the following skill areas:
And the SCANS is comprised of a three-part skills set and a five-part competency matrix:
SCANS was selected as a foundation, or baseline skills listing, appropriate to organize the EnterTech curriculum.
SCANS Basic Skills
Reading:
Locates, understands, and interprets written information in prose and documents--including manuals, graphs, and schedules--to perform tasks; learns from text by determining the main idea or essential message; identifies relevant details, facts, and specifications; infers or locates the meaning of unknown or technical vocabulary; and judges the accuracy, appropriateness, style, and plausibility of reports, proposals, or theories of other writers.
Writing:
Communicates thoughts, ideas, information, and messages in writing; records information completely and accurately; composes and creates documents such as letters, directions, manuals, reports, proposals, graphs, flow charts; uses language, style, organization, and format appropriate to the subject matter, purpose, and audience. Includes supporting documentation and attends to level of detail; checks, edits, and revises for correct information, appropriate emphasis, form, grammar, spelling, and punctuation.
Arithmetic/Mathematics:
Performs basic computations; uses basic numerical concepts such as whole numbers and percentages in practical situations; makes reasonable estimates of arithmetic results without a calculator; and uses tables, graphs, diagrams, and charts to obtain or convey quantitative information. Approaches practical problems by choosing appropriately from a variety of mathematical techniques; uses quantitative data to construct logical explanations for real world situations; expresses mathematical ideas and concepts orally and in writing; and understands the role of chance in the occurrence and prediction of events.
Listening:
Receives, attends to, interprets, and responds to verbal messages and other cues such as body language in ways that are appropriate to the purpose; for example, to comprehend; to learn; to critically evaluate; to appreciate; or to support the speaker.
Speaking:
Organizes ideas and communicates oral messages appropriate to listeners and situations; participates in conversation, discussion, and group presentations; selects an appropriate medium for conveying a message; uses verbal languages and other cues such as body language appropriate in style, tone, and level of complexity to the audience and the occasion; speaks clearly and communicates message; understands and responds to listener feed back; and asks questions when needed.
SCANS Thinking Skills
Creative Thinking:
Uses imagination freely, combines ideas or information in new ways, makes connections between seemingly unrelated ideas, and reshapes goals in ways that reveal new possibilities.
Decision Making:
Specifies goals and constraints, generates alternatives, considers risks, and evaluates and chooses best alternatives.
Problem Solving:
Recognizes that a problem exists (i.e., there is a discrepancy between what is and what should or could be), identifies possible reasons for the discrepancy, and
devises and implements a plan of action to resolve it. Evaluates and monitors progress, and revises plan as indicated by findings.
Seeing Things in the Mind's Eye:
Organizes and processes symbols, pictures, graphs, objects or other information; for example, see a building from blue print, a system's operation from schematics, the flow of work activities from narrative descriptions, or the taste of food from reading a recipe.
Knowing How to Learn:
Recognizes and can use learning techniques to apply and adapt new knowledge and skills in both familiar and changing situations. Involves being aware of learning tools such as personal learning styles (visual, aural, etc.), formal learning strategies (note taking or clustering items that share some characteristics), and informal learning strategies (awareness of unidentified false assumptions that may lead to faulty conclusions).
Reasoning:
Discovers a rule or principle underlying the relationship between two or more objects and applies it in solving a problem. For example, uses logic to draw conclusions from available information, extracts rules or principles from a set of objects or written text; applies rules and principles to a new situation, or determines which conclusions are correct when given a set of facts and a set of conclusions.
SCANS Personal Qualities
Responsibility:
Exerts a high level of effort and perseverance towards goal attainment. Works hard to become excellent at doing tasks by setting high standards, paying attention to details, working well, and displaying a high level concentration even when assigned an unpleasant task. Displays high standards of attendance, punctuality, enthusiasm, vitality, and optimism in approaching and completing tasks.
Self-Esteem:
Believes in own self-worth and maintains a positive view of self; demonstrates knowledge of own skills and abilities; is aware of impact on others; and knows own emotional capacity and needs and how to address them.
Sociability:
Demonstrates understanding, friendliness, adaptability, empathy, and politeness in new and on-going group settings. Asserts self in familiar and unfamiliar social situations; relates well to others; responds appropriately as the situation requires; and takes an interest in what others say and do.
Self-Management:
Assesses own knowledge, skills, and abilities accurately; sets well-defined and realistic personal goals; monitors progress toward goal attainment and motivates self through goal achievement; exhibits self-control and responds to feedback unemotionally and non-defensively; is a "self-starter."
Integrity/Honesty:
Can be trusted. Recognizes when faced with making a decision or exhibiting behavior that may break with commonly held personal or societal values; understands the impact of violating these beliefs and codes on an organization, self, and others; and chooses an ethical course of action.
SCANS Five Workplace CompetenciesResources:
Identifies, organizes, plans, and allocates resources.
Time--Selects goal-relevant activities, ranks them, allocates time, and prepares and follows schedules
Money--Uses or prepares budgets, makes forecasts, keeps records, and makes adjustments to meet objectives
Material and Facilities--Acquires, stores, allocates, and uses materials or space efficiently
Human Resources--Assesses skills and distributes work accordingly, evaluates performance and provides feedback
Interpersonal:
Works with others.
Participates as Member of a Team--contributes to group effort
Teaches Others New Skills
Serves Clients/Customers--works to satisfy customers' expectations
Exercises Leadership--communicates ideas to justify position, persuades and convinces others, responsibly challenges existing procedures and policies
Negotiates--works toward agreements involving exchange of resources, resolves divergent interests
Works with Diversity--works well with men and women from diverse backgrounds
Information:
Acquires and uses information.
Acquires and Evaluates Information
Organizes and Maintains Information
Interprets and Communicates Information
Uses Computers to Process Information.
Systems:
Understands complex inter-relationships.
Understands Systems--knows how social, organizational, and technological systems work and operates effectively with them
Monitors and Corrects Performance--distinguishes trends, predicts impacts on systems operations, diagnoses deviations in systems' performance and corrects malfunctions
Improves or Designs Systems--suggests modifications to existing systems and develops new or alternative systems to improve performance
Technology:
Works with a variety of technologies.
Selects Technology--chooses procedures, tools or equipment including computers and related technologies
Applies Technology to Task--Understands overall intent and proper procedures for setup and operation of equipment
Maintains and Troubleshoots Equipment--Prevents, identifies, or solves problems with equipment, including computers and other technologies.
2.3 Job Descriptions and Task Lists
The following EnterTech coalition employers submitted job descriptions or task lists for their entry-level positions:
The information garnered from these materials was reviewed by the advisory teams and incorporated into the knowledge, skills and abilities listing. Appendix F contains the job descriptions and task lists provided, with the names of the companies blackened to protect confidentiality.
Additional job descriptions appropriate to Texas technology industries also were selected from the U.S. Department of Labors Dictionary of Occupational Titles (DOT) and from the Texas SOICC electronic version of the DOT, called the Occupational and Skill Computer-Assisted Researcher or OSCAR. Occupational titles reviewed included:
Appendix F also contains the additional job descriptions and task lists selected by the EnterTech advisory teams.
Section 3. Research and analyze entry-level jobs in the technology industries and the related supply and service industries to determine the knowledge, skills and abilities required for those particular jobs, if needed.
Augmenting the cumulative research efforts, Work Keys profiles were collected, performed or are scheduled for selected entry-level positions.
The following Work Keys profiles were contributed to the project by coalition employers:
ACT Inc. provided skill levels for the following occupational titles:
Assembler Electromechanical
Assembler Semiconductor
Computer Operator
Electronics Assembler
Material Handler
Order Clerk
Packager, Machine
Shipping and Receiving Clerk.
Additionally, the Workforce Development Services group provided complete Work Keys profiles of the following jobs:
Laboratory Technician
Production Cell Team Member
Call Center Officer.
Work Keys profiles have been performed by the EnterTech Project or are scheduled:
Copies of completed profiles are in Appendix G. The remaining job profiling will continue through January 1999. The EnterTech Project competency matrix will be adjusted to reflect any necessary modifications or additions.
The skills sets verified to-date include the following Work Keys levels:
| Skill | Profile Levels | Range |
| Reading for Information | 3-5 | 3-7 |
| Applied Mathematics | 3-5 | 3-7 |
| Listening | 4-5 | 1-5 |
| Writing | 3-4 | 1-5 |
| Locating Information | 3-4 | 3-6 |
| Teamwork | 3-6 | 3-6 |
| Applied Technology | 3-5 | 3-6 |
| Observation | 4-5 | 3-6 |
Work Keys profiling involves the following steps:
Profiling is conducted with incumbent workers who select and sort the task requirements of their job. The criticality of each task is factored through combining the relative time spent at the task and the overall importance of the task. On-the-job behaviors and activities that require a particular skill, such as reading manuals or adding a list of numbers, are categorized into the Work Keys skill areas and levels. Entry requirements are usually at least one skill level below the expected performance level of an incumbent worker with several months on-the-job experience.
Section 4. Matrix of the knowledge, skills and abilities required of the EnterTech Project graduate and by technology industry employers.
From the curriculum research, national skills standards, employer-gathered information, and Work Keys job profiles, a preliminary matrix of performance objectives was created for the EnterTech Project. The matrix is divided into eight major domains:
Each domain is divided into "knowledge" categories, the sub-related "competencies," followed by a listing of proposed performance objectives.
Career Management and Employee Awareness
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Seek and Gain Employment | Determine career goals |
|
| Understand employer's needs |
|
|
| Conduct job search |
|
|
| Apply for position |
|
|
| Interview for position |
|
|
| Retain Employment | Understand employer's organizational structure |
|
| Understand policies and procedures |
|
|
| Function effectively within the formal and informal codes of the social and organizational system |
|
|
| Perform job according to direction |
|
|
| Advance within organization |
|
|
| Understand customer relationship to business |
|
Affective Skills
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Individual Affective Skills | Develop positive self-image |
|
| Positive attitude |
|
|
| Manage personal stress |
|
|
| Perform work responsibly |
|
|
| Comply with established safety practices |
|
|
| Manages assigned workload independently |
|
|
| Exhibit honesty and integrity |
|
|
| Interpersonal Affective Skills | Effectively communicate messages, ideas, and opinions |
|
| Use business telephone skills |
|
|
| Give and receive criticism and suggestions |
|
|
| Work cooperatively |
|
|
| Negotiate and resolve conflicts |
|
|
| Work with diverse group of employers, employees, and customers |
|
|
| Communicate effectively with customers and clients |
|
Manage and Allocate Resources
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Information | Identify, secure, evaluate, process, and/or store information |
|
| Use organizational systems for information |
|
|
| Create organizational systems for information |
|
|
| Time and Schedule | Self-management |
|
| Coordinate others |
|
|
| Financial Resources | Uses budgets at work |
|
| Understand financial systems related to productivity |
|
|
| Basic Office Tools | Understand and use common business tools |
|
| Understand computer operation |
|
Basic Skills: Oral Communication
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Speaking | Effectively convey a message by spoken communication |
|
| Clarify and verify shared meaning |
|
|
| Share organized information orally |
|
|
| Listening | Use active listening skills. |
|
| Follow spoken directions |
|
|
| Critical listening |
|
Basic Skills: Written Communication
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Reading for Information | Obtain information from written materials |
|
| Interpret meaning of written materials |
|
|
| Writing and Creating Graphics for Information |
Organize information for writing |
|
| Compose written information such as letters, directions, manuals, reports, proposals, graphs, flow charts |
|
|
| Writing and Creating Graphics for Information (continued) | Electronic Communication |
|
| Record information |
|
|
| Interpreting Visual Information | Obtain information from graphic displays |
|
| Obtain information from visual inspection |
|
Basic Skills: Arithmetic and Mathematics
| Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Basic Math | Understand numbers, arithmetic operations and numerical concepts |
|
| Understand geometric concepts |
|
|
| Calculate formulas |
|
|
| Applied Math | Calculate formulas |
|
| Apply concepts of measurement |
|
|
| Communicate with numerical information in visual form |
|
|
| Apply mathematical concepts to solve problems |
|
Problem-Solving and Systems Thinking
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Problem Solving | Define problem |
|
| Apply problem-solving techniques |
|
|
| Generate solutions |
|
|
| Evaluate effectiveness of solution |
|
|
| Develop problem-solving strategies |
|
|
| Systems Thinking | Understands and can evaluate systems |
|
On-going Learning
Knowledge |
Competency |
Performance Objective |
| Acquire New Skills and Information | Manage on-going learning |
|
| Learn from variety of sources |
|
|
| Knows How to Learn | Share learning with others |
|
| Use learning strategies |
|
|
| Change Management | Demonstrate flexibility and adaptability in workplace |
|
Section 5. Conclusion
EnterTech Project coalition members are currently reviewing the knowledge, skills and abilities matrix. The Resources, Knowledge, Skills and Abilities Advisory Team and employer representatives are providing responses through a survey form (Appendix H). With this feedback, along with the completion of the additional Work Keys job profiles, appropriate modifications will be incorporated into the matrix.
The matrix represents a conceptual framework from which to develop the EnterTech Project curriculum. Building from this needs analysis, performance objectives, assessment activities and instructional strategies can be determined for the specific knowledge, skills and abilities.
Among the most important lessons to impart are the basic employability skills and abilities of teamwork, interpersonal communications, problem solving, organizational thinking, and career management. Along with enhancements to basic knowledge in mathematics, writing, reading, and computer skills in context with technology industry job tasks, the EnterTech curriculum can meet the needs of employers and targeted learners alike.
Bibliography
ACT Inc. Work Keys Skill Scales. 1996.
Cyberstates Update. American Electronics Association. 1998.
The Monthly Labor Review. August 1998.
High-Tech Jobs Outnumber Oil and Gas in Texas, Austin-American Statesman. Tuesday, August 25, 1998.
Looking Toward Tomorrow: Industry & Occupation Projections to the Year 2005. Texas Workforce Commission, Labor Market Information Department. April 1998.
October 9, 1998 EnterTech Coalition meeting. Electronic data gathered from the IBM Team Focus Decision software.
OSCAR Occupational Characteristics Narratives, Texas SOICC. 1996.
Regenstein, Marsha, Jack A. Meyer and Jennifer Dickemper Hicksl. "Job Prospects for Welfare Recipients: Employers Speak Out." Urban Institute, Washington D.C. Series A, No. A-25. August 1998.
Report of Governors Science and Technology Council, 1998.
Tait, Jane, Development Systems Corp., Final Report on Job Profiles and Skills Assessment Results for Dell Computer Inc., 1997.
Targeting Your Labor Market, Texas SOICC. Reprinted July 1998.
Texas Business and Education Coalition.
What Work Requires of Schools, A SCANS Report for America 2000, U.S. Department of Labor. 1991.