Book Review:
Murray Richtel, Reviewing Norman Dorsen & Leon Friedman’s
Disorder in the Court: Report of the Association of the Bar of
the City of New York, Special Committee on Courtroom Conduct, 53
TEXAS L . REV. 188 (1974).
Abstract:
Disorder in the Court is a systematic attempt to analyze the
causes and scope of the problem of courtroom disruption. The
most significant finding of the book is that there is no serious
problem of disruption in American courts, and that the
well-publicized disorder of the Chicago conspiracy trial and the
New York Black Panther trial were not representative of any
trend. The book attempts to define the proper roles of
participants in trials, reexamine legal rules governing the
conduct of participants, appraise proposals for change, and
consider the relationship of stresses in society to courtroom
disorder. Professor Richtel argues that the strength of the book
is in its collection of data and as a reference work; the
weakness of Disorder in the Court is its attempt at in-depth
analysis of that data.