Note:
Donald R. Joseph, Jr., Absolute Judicial Privilege Extends to
Verbatim Publication by West Publishing Company of Allegedly
Defamatory Judicial Opinion, 55 TEXAS L. REV. 1103 (1977).
Abstract:
In its Federal Supplement, West Publishing Company printed the
defamatory comments made by a federal district court judge about
the motives of the plaintiff even after a disciplinary board
vindicated the plaintiff’s conduct. In Lowenschuss v. West
Publishing Co., 542 F.2d 180 (3d Cir. 1976), the court held that
the defendant’s verbatim publication of judicial opinions and
decisions serves as intrinsic judicial function and is
absolutely privileged. Joseph comments that using the first
amendment right to freedom of the press would have avoided the
problems inherent in bringing a defendant under the legislative,
executive, or judicial privileges, while still maintaining the
desired protection for verbatim reports of judicial opinions.