Article:
Thomas O. McGarity, The Courts, the Agencies, and NEPA
Threshold Issues, 55 TEXAS L. REV. 801 (1977).
Abstract:
Congress passed the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 to
ensure that federal agencies act only after thorough
consideration of environmental effects and alternatives. Section
102(2)(C) requires that an agency prepare an environmental
impact statement for all “major Federal actions significantly
affecting the quality of the human environment,” but despite a
profusion of litigation, the scope of this section remains
largely undefined.
Professor McGarity surveys the broad categories of agency
decision-making and argues that courts and agencies alike should
construe section 102(2)(C) in light of the informational purpose
of NEPA, which is to disclose relevant environmental information
to the agencies, Congress, and the public. He contends that the
Act independently empowers an agency to employ environmental
considerations in reaching decisions and that the Supreme Court
decisions which read section 102(2)(C) narrowly and mechanically
frustrate the congressional purpose.