Note:
David Randolph Smith, Section 1983: Pendent Party
Jurisdiction Not Available When Congress Has Expressly or
Impliedly Refused to Extend Jurisdiction to the Pendent Party,
55 TEXAS L. REV. 941 (1977).
Abstract:
After Monica Aldinger was fired from her job at the Spokane
County Treasurer’s Office for living with her boyfriend, she
filed suit in federal district court against county officials
under section 1983 of the Civil Rights Act and against Spokane
County under Washington state law. In Aldinger v. Howard, 427
U.S. 1 (1976), the Supreme Court affirmed the Ninth Circuit and
held that joinder of a municipal corporation for purposes of
asserting a state-law claim not within federal diversity
jurisdiction is beyond the jurisdiction of the district court.
Smith argues that Aldinger places civil rights litigants in an
unfortunate position. A plaintiff must either incur the costs of
proceeding in both state and federal courts or bring the suit in
state court and risk possible bias in favor of a defendant
political subdivision.