Article:
William F. Cockrell, Jr., Invalidation of Federal Petroleum
Regulations on the Basis of Procedural Rulemaking Deficiencies,
57 Texas L. Rev. 535 (1979).
Abstract:
In assessing the validity of general federal price controls, one
court succinctly summarized what has become a major focus of
attack on the federal government’s regulation of petroleum
products as a “cavalier disregard of procedural requirements.”
Congress imposed procedural restraints on federal agency
regulation of the petroleum industry to ensure that the
bureaucracy’s inexperience with the oil and gas industry would
be tempered by the knowledge of those most familiar with its
complexities—oil and gas company personnel. Thus, the regulated
entities have never viewed the pervasive procedural infirmities
of the present regulatory scheme as mere technical deficiencies.
The courts are becoming more willing to invalidate regulations
promulgated without adherence to statutory procedural
requirements. This article focuses on the increased judicial
sensitivity to the need for procedural regularity in the
promulgation of petroleum regulations, and the resulting
emergence of standards by which to assess procedural challenges
to the regulatory scheme.