Book Review:
William C. Powers, Jr., A Methodological Perspective on the
Duty to Act, Reviewing “The Duty to Act: Tort Law, Power, &
Public Policy” by Marshall S. Shapo, 57 Texas L. Rev. 523
(1979).
Abstract:
In The Duty to Act, Marshall Shapo proposes a theory of tort
liability for cases concerning a failure to render aid, based on
“the idea that duties [to act] arise from power.” He surveys
dozens of duty-to-act cases and argues that an understanding of
the parties’ relative power and dependence illuminates the
theory of decision. The book is divided into two parts, the
first dealing with duties of individuals to expend energy and
resources to benefit others, the second dealing with
governmental liability raises some distinct issues, Shapo’s
principal insight into the power and dependence relationship
transcends the dichotomy between governmental and private
defendants.