Article:
Grover Rees III, Throwing Away the Key: The
Unconstitutionality of the Equal Rights Amendment Extension,
58 TEXAS L. REV. 875 (1980).
Abstract:
The deadline for passing the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) has
passed. Congress undoubtedly has the authority to create an
additional period for states to ratify the ERA, but Congress has
overstepped its bounds by extending the validity of the existing
ratifications beyond their expiration dates. This article
responds to Professor Ginsburg’s recent article supporting
Congress’s action. This article suggests the importance of two
principles of constitutional amendment: 1) the Constitution can
be amended only by consensus, and 2) the words of documents are
prima facie evidence of the intent of those that executed the
document. The article concludes that due respect to these two
constitutional principles can only be given by insisting that a
state legislature, and not Congress, be the only body allowed to
extend a state’s ratification. Allowing Congress to extend the
states’ ratifications against their will has important
ramifications: it sets a precedent by which a simple majority of
Congress can exercise plenary power to commandeer the amendment
process. It is important to reject this attempt by Congress.