Article:
Rogers M. Smith, The Constitution and Autonomy, 60 Texas
L. Rev. 175 (1982).
Abstract:
In this Article, Professor Smith identifies the doctrinal
developments of autonomy as part of a broad and basic
transformation in liberal political theory and American
constitutional thought, instead of treating these developments
as separate and unrelated. He states that the rise of autonomy
as a fundamental value can be discerned not only in cases
involving contraception, abortion, privacy, and so on, but also
in expanding and broadening of free exercise claims, free speech
guarantees, and procedural due process. Further, he notes that
the Burger Court is replacing the partial recognition given by
the Warren Court to autonomy with a jurisprudence that defends
as autonomous only conduct sanctioned by conventional
majoritarian morality. The article proposes some alternative
courses “that might better redeem the hopes for personal freedom
of both early and modern liberal theory.”