Book Review:
Grover Rees III, Cathedrals Without Walls: A View from the
Outside (reviewing Guido Calabresi’s A Common Law for the
Age of Statutes (1982)), 61 TEXAS L. REV. 347 (1982).
Abstract:
In this Book Review, Professor Rees argues that Professor (now
Judge) Calabresi’s book, while offering useful commentary on the
tension between statutory and judge-made law, does not focus
enough on constitutional law and places more confidence in
judicial decision-making than Rees would. Rees’s main concern is
statutory obsolescence. He fears that judges too often run
roughshod over statutes by distinguishing them with unsound
doctrine. While Calabresi attempts to provide some guidance for
sorting out the tension between obsolete statutes and the
ability of judges to promulgate common law, Rees desires a
greater focus on constitutional law and the consequences of
Calabresi’s arguments for it.