Article:
Reed Shuldiner, A General Approach to the Taxation of
Financial Instruments, 71 Texas L. Rev. 243 (1992).
Abstract:
Shuldiner argues that the present tax treatment of financial
instruments has high social costs. He suggests that these
problems could be avoided by abandoning the current realization
system and adopting mark-to-market accounting for financial
instruments. But since the adoption of such a system is
unlikely, the author offers an alternative: expected value
taxation. The Article develops a general framework for
determining the timing of income with respect to financial
instruments within the overall confines of realization-based
accounting. The author recommends a set of uniform rules to
account for financial instruments, including dividing
instruments into their component parts and accruing income for
tax purposes based on each part’s expected future value.