Note:
George R. Ackert, An Argument for Exempting Prestige Goods
from the Per Se Ban on Resale Price Maintenance, 73 TEXAS L.
REV. 1185 (1995).
Abstract:
Retail Price Maintenance (RPM) is an agreement between a seller
and a retailer that requires the retailer to sell the product
for no less than some specified price. In 1911, the Supreme
Court made RPM illegal in the famous Dr. Miles opinion (Dr.
Miles Medical Co. v. John D. Park & Sons Co.). This note
argues that if the Supreme Court continues to adhere to the per
se rule of Dr. Miles, it should treat prestige goods
differently. It argues against the traditional justifications
for the ban on RPM, such as dealer cartels, manufacturer
cartels, and high prices, do not apply to prestige goods. It
also puts forth new arguments in favor of allowing an exception
to the ban on RPM based on the nature of prestige goods,
including price image, the free rider problem, entry
facilitation, and choice of distribution.