Article:
Jonathan R. Siegel, The Hidden Source of Congress’s Power
to Abrogate State Sovereign Immunity, 73 TEXAS L. REV. 539
(1995).
Abstract:
Jonathan Siegel asserts that the debate over the source and
scope of Congress's power to abrogate state sovereign immunity
is unnecessary. He argues that Congress has, and always has had,
the ability to abrogate Eleventh Amendment immunity using any of
its powers that allow it to regulate state behavior. In a
three-step analysis, advancing from suits by the United States,
through suits in the name of the United States, to suits by
individuals in their own names, the author reaches the
conclusion that the source of Congress's power to abrogate state
immunity lies in the power of the United States to sue the
states. By using a statutory device similar to a qui tam action,
Congress could authorize individuals to bring suits against
states for the violation of any duty that Congress may
constitutionally impose on the states; the availability of this
device implies both practically and theoretically that Congress
should be able to authorize individuals to sue states.