Texas Astronomers Measure Most Massive, Most Unusual Black Hole Using Hobby-Eberly Telescope

Nov. 28, 2012

FORT DAVIS, Texas —

The black hole at the center of galaxy NGC 1277 is eleven times wider than Neptune's orbit around the sun. Click to download this and more images to accompany this release.

Astronomers have used the Hobby-Eberly Telescope at The University of Texas at Austin's McDonald Observatory to measure the mass of what may be the most massive black hole yet — 17 billion times our sun’s mass — in galaxy NGC 1277. The unusual black hole makes up 14 percent of its galaxy's mass, rather than the usual 0.1 percent. This galaxy and several more in the same study could change theories about how black holes and galaxies form and evolve. The work will appear in the journal Nature on Nov. 29.

NGC 1277 lies 220 million light-years away in the constellation Perseus. The galaxy is only 10 percent the size and mass of our Milky Way. Despite NGC 1277's diminutive size, the black hole at its heart is more than 11 times as wide as Neptune's orbit around the sun.

"This is a really oddball galaxy," said team member Karl Gebhardt of The University of Texas at Austin. "It's almost all black hole. This could be the first object in a new class of galaxy-black hole systems." Furthermore, the most massive black holes have been seen in giant blobby galaxies called "ellipticals," but this one is seen in a relatively small lens-shaped galaxy (in astronomical jargon, a "lenticular galaxy").

The find comes out of the Hobby-Eberly Telescope Massive Galaxy Survey (MGS). The study's goal is to better understand how black holes and galaxies form and grow together, a process that isn't well understood.

"At the moment there are three completely different mechanisms that all claim to explain the link between black hole mass and host galaxies' properties. We do not understand yet which of these theories is best," said Nature lead author Remco van den Bosch, who began this work while holding the W.J. McDonald postdoctoral fellowship at The University of Texas at Austin. He is now at the Max Planck Institute for Astronomy in Heidelberg, Germany.

The problem is lack of data. Astronomers know the mass of fewer than 100 black holes in galaxies. But measuring black hole masses is difficult and time-consuming. So the team developed the HET Massive Galaxy Survey to winnow down the number of galaxies that would be interesting to study more closely.

"When trying to understand anything, you always look at the extremes: the most massive and the least massive," Gebhardt said. "We chose a very large sample of the most massive galaxies in the nearby universe" to learn more about the relationship between black holes and their host galaxies.

Though still ongoing, the team has studied 700 of their 800 galaxies with HET. "This study is only possible with HET," Gebhardt said. "The telescope works best when the galaxies are spread all across the sky. This is exactly what HET was designed for."

In the current paper, the team zeroes in on the top six most massive galaxies. They found that one of those, NGC 1277, had already been photographed by Hubble Space Telescope. This provided measurements of the galaxy’s brightness at different distances from its center. When combined with HET data and various models run via supercomputer, the result was a mass for the black hole of 17 billion suns (give or take 3 billion).

"The mass of this black hole is much higher than expected," Gebhardt said. "It leads us to think that very massive galaxies have a different physical process in how their black holes grow."

Founded in 1932, The University of Texas at Austin's McDonald Observatory hosts multiple telescopes undertaking a variety of astronomical research under the darkest night skies of any professional observatory in the continental United States. McDonald is home to one of the world's largest telescopes, the 9.2-meter Hobby-Eberly Telescope, a joint project of The University of Texas at Austin, Pennsylvania State University, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, and Georg-August-Universität Göttingen. An international leader in astronomy education and outreach, the McDonald Observatory is also pioneering the next generation of astronomical research as a partner in the Giant Magellan Telescope.

Notes to editors: High-resolution images to accompany this release are available here.

McDonald Observatory also produces a web resource on black holes for public, the StarDate Black Holes Encyclopedia. The site includes articles, images, and videos on all known black holes.

For more information, contact: Rebecca Johnson, McDonald Observatory, College of Natural Sciences, 512 475 6763; Dr. Karl Gebhardt, Herman and Joan Suit Professor of Astrophysics, 512-471-1473, gebhardt@astro.as.utexas.edu

5 Comments to "Texas Astronomers Measure Most Massive, Most Unusual Black Hole Using Hobby-Eberly Telescope"

1.  Ed said on Nov. 29, 2012

If the black hole is that big, what should i imagine for the event-horizon?

2.  Adi said on Nov. 29, 2012

Wo it's to biggest. Super super. Good articles. Thanks.

3.  Mr Masten Petley said on Nov. 30, 2012

1. The black hole has consumed NGC1277 (which was once large) and is now at a tipping point and will start evaporating.
2. The black hole is consuming matter we are unable to see.
3. The black hole does not work as we think it should and is consuming something else (a dark matter black hole?)
4. The black hole has been join by another one without causing a recoil.

4.  Troy Johnson said on Dec. 13, 2012

How do we know it's a black hole? Is there synchrotron radiation present? What, if any, is the relationship, if any, between dark energy/matter and a black hole? If this is the largest black hole, what is the smallest black hole? Where did you get the figure 17 billion solar masses? How big is the Milky Way's central black hole? Does anybody really understand exactly what a black hole is?

5.  Lonnie said on Dec. 15, 2012

Hello I am trying to find Alan Scott of the DS3 telescope maker and a old freind of Jade Douglas
can any one help me?