Bnrbptyc.gif (7487 bytes)

Logotyc.gif (2193 bytes)

 

Rolling Back the Data:  Newsletter

Below is a receation of the TYC''s Employee Update.  This newsletter was distributed to TYC employees following the return of the 1998 Survey of Organizational Excellence data.  Newsletters of this type serve as excellent examples of communication results to large number of employees.

onsidebar.gif (468 bytes)

 


TYC EMPLOYEE UPDATE


Survev results tallied

Survey of Organizational Excellence indicates employee satisfaction rising

tycrr.gif (1850 bytes)Every two years, TYC and many other state agencies participate in the Survey of Organizational Excellence, a comprehensive look at employee opinions about job satisfaction and agency performance. The Survey is administered by the University of Texas at Austin. UT processes the completed forms, tabulates the results, and protects the anonymity of respondents. This year, TYC's response rate increased from 29% in the 1996 survey to 45%, showing that more TYC staff members than ever are willing to offer their input to help the agency improve. The increased response rate was good news for TYC, and so were the survey findings. The findings showed that, overall, TYC staff are more satisfied than they were two years ago with the agency's performance and with their own working conditions. The survey will help the agency improve even more by indicating the areas where employees are less satisfied or where change is needed.

What looks good:
Employees expressed the most satisfaction with these areas:

  • TYC's ability to identify and serve its customers
  • TYC's ability to work with other organizations and with its governing bodies (its board and the legislature)
  • employees' access to training
  • employment benefits and their administration

What needs work:

  • Employees expressed the least satisfaction with these areas:
  • trust and communication between employees and management
  • stress and burnout
  • employee empowerment
  • the sharing of knowledge and decision making

Constructs: A Quick Overview of the Results


What is a construct?

A survey construct represents a specific aspect of TYC's performance. A score for each construct is generated by combining the average scores for several related questions. The construct scores are an easy way to compare TYC's 1998 survey results to its results in previous years. They can also be used to compare TYC's findings to the statewide results and the results from agencies similar to TYC.

Possible scores range from 100 to 500. The higher the score, the better. For example, a higher score for the "Burnout" construct means that fewer employees are experiencing problems in this area.

Construct

1994 1996 1998 Change '94-'98
Supervisor Effectiveness 237 243 275 +38
Fairness 231 234 261 +30
Job Satisfaction 261 265 293 +32
Diversity 286 283 302 +16
Fair Pay 297 302 320 +23
Physical Environment 267 268 291 +24
Benefits 359 365 374 +15
Availability of Information 278 286 299 +21
Time & Stress Mgmnt. 270 268 291 +21
Burnout 263 270 294 +31
Empowerment 253 256 279 +26

What is a benchmark?

The benchmarking categories are a way of comparing TYC's results to those from agencies that are similar to TYC in size (measured in Full-Time Employees) or mission (public safety or criminal justice).

The table below shows that TYC performed well in comparison to the statewide results and also in comparison to the agencies in our benchmarking categories.

Construct TYC Statewide FTE Mission
Supervisor Effectiveness 275 258 265 244
Fairness 261 254 259 232
Job Satisfaction 293 292 299 275
Diversity 302 296 301 285
Fair Pay 320 296 292 294
Physical Environment 291 296 310 265
Benefits 374 366 362 362
Availability of Information 299 289 290 279
Time and Stress Mgmnt. 291 306 316 278
Burnout 294 285 294 271
Empowerment 279 270 276 261

There are twenty constructs in all. These tables show only eleven of them. For a graph showing TYC's scores for all twenty constructs, compared to the scores for agencies in its mission category.

Other facts from the survey's findings:

  • TYC's employees tended to agree with each other about what the agency is doing well. They tended to disagree about which areas most need improvement.
  • There were variations among groups in the agency in their responses to the questions. For example, employees in Operations or Clinical Care might express more satisfaction about a particular topic than employees in Education or Corrections.
  • Because TYC has expanded rapidly over the past two years, questions asking employees to assess the agency's performance over time tended to receive many "don't know/not applicable" responses.

Top Ten Questions

Below are listed the ten questions that received the highest average scores. A high score indicates a high level of satisfaction. Possible responses to these questions were as follows: (1) strongly disagree; (2) disagree; (3) feel neutral; (4) agree; (5) strongly agree; and (6) don't know/not applicable.

Question Score
We know who our customers are. 4.14
I am satisfied with the sick leave benefit offered by my employer. 3.95
I am satisfied with the holiday benefit offered by my employer. 3.94
(TIE) I am satisfied with the medical insurance benefit offered by my employer. & I am satisfied with the vacation benefit offered by my employer. 3.86
Sexual harassment is not tolerated in this organization. 3.84
(TIE) We work well with the public. & The benefits and compensation packages were adequately explained to me when I was hired. 3.81
Benefits can be selected to meet individual needs. 3.78
1 am satisfied with the retirement benefit offered by my employer. 3.77
(TIE) Benefits are comparable to those offered in other jobs. & The overall benefits and compensation packages offered by my employer were a consideration for me to take this position. 3.72
(TIE) We develop services to match our customers' needs.& Training is made available to employees so that they can do their job better. 3.67

Bottom Ten Questions

Below are listed the ten questions that received the lowest average score.

Questions beginning with "Assess . . . " are over time comparison" questions. They asked employees to assess the agency's performance over the last two years. For these questions, employees were given the following responses to choose from: (1) the organization is performing much worse; (2) the organization is performing worse; (3) the organization is performing about the same; (4) the organization is performing better; (5) the organization is performing much better; and (6) don't know/not applicable. A higher score for these questions means a higher level of satisfaction.

Questions followed by an asterisk (*) are negatively phrased questions for which scoring was reversed to maintain scoring convention. Therefore, higher average scores for these questions are desired.

Question Score
There is a basic trust among employees and management. 2.43
People who challenge the status quo are valued. 2.47
Management knows whether an individual employee's life goals are compatible with organizational goals. 2.49
Assess the level of stress and burnout that is experienced in this organization. 2.50
Employees feel that they must always go through channels to get their work done.* 2.51
Assess the level of bureaucracy in this organization. 2.54
The right information gets to the right people at the right time. 2.57
(TIE) Raises and promotions are designed to ensure that workers are rewarded solely for their performance. & Promotion recommendations are made by a team of evaluators. 2.58
(TIE) Information and knowledge are shared openly in this organization. & TYC is successful at achieving Number 5 of our Guiding Principles which is, "TYC recognizes staff as its most valuable resource." 2.63
Decision making and control are given to employees doing the actual work. 2.67


Graph of TYC's construct scores compared to average scores for agencies in our mission category (Public Safety and Criminal Justice)

Constructs

1. Supervisor Effectiveness
2. Fairness
3. Team Effectiveness
4. Job Satisfaction
5. Diversity
6. Fair Pay
7. Adequacy of Physical Environment
8. Benefits
9. Employment Development
10. Change Oriented
11. Goal Oriented
12. Holographic (Consistency)
13. Strategic Orientation
14. Quality
15. Internal Communication
16. Availability of Information
17. External Communication
18. Time & Stress Management
19. Burnout
20. Empowerment

The Next Step

The survey results have given TYC's leadership valuable information about employee attitudes and opinions. The next step in using the survey to improve the agency is to gather feedback from employees on the meaning of the results. This newsletter contains only a few of the survey's findings. A more complete packet of information has been distributed to superintendents and administrators. They have been encouraged to hold voluntary meetings at which employees can find out more about the survey's results in reference to their own work locations. Employees are also encouraged to analyze and discuss these results.

Does the information confirm what you already knew, or does it contradict your personal knowledge? Does it offer insight into problems or dilemmas you have been experiencing? How could the TYC improve its performance in the areas the survey has identified as weak? What ideas do you have on how TYC can use the results of the survey?

 

[ TOP OF PAGE ]

 

The Survey of Organizational Excellence Home Page
Last Update:  December 17, 1998
Questions and comments to: soe@uts.cc.utexas.edu
School of Social Work at UT Austin

Copyright © Survey of Organizational Excellence. All rights reserved.